there may have been a manger, but it wasn’t a stable

December 17th, 2018 | 1 min read

What, then, does it mean for the kataluma to have ‘no space’? It means that many, like Joseph and Mary, have travelled to Bethlehem, and the family guest room is already full, probably with other relatives who arrived earlier. So Joseph and Mary must stay with the family itself, in the main room of the house, and there Mary gives birth. The most natural place to lay the baby is in the hay-filled depressions at the lower end of the house where the animals are fed. The idea that they were in a stable, away from others, alone and outcast, is grammatically and culturally implausible. In fact, it is hard to be alone at all in such contexts.

Matthew Loftus

Matthew Loftus teaches and practices Family Medicine in Baltimore and East Africa. His work has been featured in Christianity Today, Comment, & First Things and he is a regular contributor for Christ and Pop Culture. You can learn more about his work and writing at www.MatthewAndMaggie.org

Topics:

Bible

History

there may have been a manger, but it wasn’t a stable

Related Articles

Renewing Public Protestantism: Seminaries

Christ Mirrors Back Our World

When the Therapeutic God Isn’t Sufficient

The Case for Pew Bibles

Ruth’s Prequel to the Christmas Story

St Paul the Word Sower

Esther and the Theology of Thanksgiving

Biblical Nationalism

Why We Never Move Past the Gospel of John

Ecclesiastes’ Cure for Depression

This Is My Body Given for You

60 Questions for Pro-Choice Christians

Aardvarks and Alphabets

Revisiting the Sacrifice of Isaac

The Case for Rearranging the Old Testament Books

Book Review: Paul and the Power of Grace by John M. G. Barclay

The Book of Revelation is for the Church

Book Review: Sanctifying Interpretation by Chris E. W. Green

Advent IV: The Coming(s) of Christ and Our Hope

Straightening Out the Bible?: The Translator’s Text and Audience

In Defense of Premodern Exegesis

The Sweeping View of the Gospel in Colossians

Martin Luther, the Rule of Faith, and the Bible

On The Baptist Faith and Message and Theistic Evolution

“Are You Alone Wise?”: Luther’s Answers for Today’s Protestants